The Deflation Threat and Its Solution


Deflation is defined by (mainstream) economists as ‘a sustained period of decline in a broad measure of prices, that is, a persistent decline in broad price indices’. Let’s accept that definition for the moment.

Donald Luskin –a famous financial analyst in the US– described Deflation  as the greatest threat an economy may suffer. He was talking about the US economy in 2001. Let’s see what he said about the deflation threat:

that’s going to be a world of hurt. If you thought inflation was a nightmare, wait till you live through a deflation. Prices of everything eventually go down — stocks, real estate, wages…the whole thing. You’re a little poorer every day.

And if you’re in debt, then you’re really in trouble. You’ll still have to make those same mortgage payments even though the value of your house is going down every month.

But that doesn’t mean that deflation is any bed of roses for lenders, either. Sure, it’s nice to have locked in a stream of payments in money that will buy you more and more apples and paper clips and houses as prices collapse. But you’ll never get the money, because the borrowers will all default. We’re seeing that happen already, with corporate bond defaults running at record levels.

So, deflation is a nightmare for everyone. Of course, deflation is seen as a permanent phenomenon, a downward spiral which would send and keep the whole economy in a deep hole. But the smart academic guys and the wise central planners have the cure to avoid this.

After the paragraphs above, Luskin gives us some hope. Well, not so, when one reads it in 2010. If you thought Krugman was nuts for asking Greenspan to create a housing bubble in 2001-2002, how should Luskin be described for saying the following?:

There’s still time for Alan Greenspan to save the world again, before we slip over the edge into a savage deflationary spiral, the evil mirror image of the inflationary spiral of the 1970s. But at this point the cure probably won’t be achieved simply by lowering interest rates…. No, to cure this recession Alan Greenspan is going to have to abandon interest rate targeting and focus on simply manufacturing the money that the economy needs.

Whoa. May I wonder whether the current crisis have something to do with Greenspan’s solution at that time? Such a weird way to save the world…

I see Luskin’s proposal not so different from some policies that have been proposed in recent times to fight against deflation. Now for instance, raising inflation expectations is being discussed among the Federal Reserve officials. Will the outcome of these policies be similar to that of Greenspan’s “solution” to deflation?

[More on Deflation soon]


1 The Deflation Threat and Its Solution (Saving the World from Collapse) - Learning: a never-ending process, día

what proponents of inflation, like Donald Luskin, said in 2001, when they saw a deflation threat. Read more. Filed under: donald luskin, deflationary spiral, deflation   // // // //

2 Todos (los incompetentes) contra Peter Schiff en CNBC « Procesos de aprendizaje, día

prever un colapso económico, etc. El video es de Noviembre de 2007. Aparece nuestro amigo Donald Luskin, que parece que se salió de rositas después de recomendar a Greenspan imprimir todo el dinero

3 Should We Accept the Conventional Wisdom About Deflation? « Procesos de aprendizaje, día

takes, a  nightmare which is much more feared than inflation itself. In a previous post I showed Donald Luskin’s position on this. The question I will address is the following: Based on what we know about deflation, should this